El modelo irlandés de protección de los derechos fundamentales

  1. Escobar Roca, Guillermo 1
  1. 1 Universidad de Alcalá
    info

    Universidad de Alcalá

    Alcalá de Henares, España

    ROR https://ror.org/04pmn0e78

Revista:
Teoría y realidad constitucional

ISSN: 1139-5583

Año de publicación: 2020

Título del ejemplar: Encuesta sobre la Protección de Datos Personales

Número: 46

Páginas: 511-539

Tipo: Artículo

DOI: 10.5944/TRC.46.2020.29129 DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openDialnet editor

Otras publicaciones en: Teoría y realidad constitucional

Resumen

El modelo irlandés de derechos fundamentales resulta de utilidad para la comparación con España. Como elementos positivos que podrían inspirar una mejora de nuestro modelo pueden mencionarse: la apertura expresa y argumentada del catálogo de los derechos; un mecanismo institucional de declaración de incompatibilidad entre la ley nacional y el CEDH; el llamamiento frecuente al referéndum de reforma constitucional; y un sistema más accesible y menos politizado de control de constitucionalidad de las leyes. Como problemas comunes a ambos países, que manifiestan su retraso en relación con las tendencias recientes del Derecho internacional y de la doctrina, cabe mencionar: una resistencia a superar la concepción formal de la igualdad y a reconocer derechos fundamentales sociales, y un uso débil e incoherente del principio de proporcionalidad.

Referencias bibliográficas

  • I. BACICK, “Future directions for the Constitution”, en E. Carolan y O. Doyle (eds.), The Irish Constitution: Governance and Values, Thomson-Round Hall, Dublín, 2008,
  • H. BECKER y otros, Human Rights Law, Oxford University Press, 4ª ed., 2012.
  • W. BINCHY, “The Supreme Court of Ireland”, en B. Dickson (ed.), Judicial Activism in Common Law Supreme Courts, Oxford, 2007
  • A. BRADY, en “The Vindication of Constitutional Welfare Rights: Beyond the Deprivation of Liberty”, Dublin University Law Journal, nº 40 (2).
  • N. BUCKLEY, “Merging principles of public law: towards proportionality in an irish context”, The Irish Jurist, nº 39, 2004.
  • C. CASEY y D. MCCORMACK-GEORGE, “An Analysis of the Right to Shelter in Irish Law for Children and Adults”, Irish Jurist, nº 154.
  • D. M. CLARKE, “Unenumerated Rights in Constitutional Law”, Dublin University Law Journal, nº 34, 2011.
  • D. CLARKE, “The Role of Natural Law in Irish Constitutional Law”, Irish Jurist, nº 17, 1982
  • T. COCHRANE, “A General Public Law Duty to Provide Reasons: Why New Zealand Should Follow the Irish Supreme Court”, New Zealand Journal of Public and International Law, vol. 11, nº 3, 2013.
  • E. DALY, “Reappraising Judicial Supremacy in the Irish Constitutional Tradition”, en L. Cahillane, J. Gallen y T. Hickey (eds.), Judges, Politics and the Irish Constitution, Manchester University Press, 2017.
  • E. DALY y T. HICKEY, The political theory of the Irish Constitution, Manchester University Press, 2015.
  • F. DE LONDRAS, “In defence of judicial innovation and constitutional evolution”, en L. Cahillane y otros (eds.), Judges, Politics and the Irish Constitution, Manchester University Press, 2017.
  • E. DEWHURST, “Human Dignity in Ireland”, en P. Becchi y C. Mathis (eds.), Handbook of Human Dignity in Europe, Springer, Cham, 2018.
  • E. DEWHURST, N. HIGGINS y L. WATKINS, Principles of Irish Human Rights Law, Clarus Press, Dublín, 2012
  • F. DE LONDRAS, “Declarations of Incompatibility under the ECHR Act 2003: A Workable Transplant?”, Statute Law Review, nº 35, 2014.
  • F. DE LONDRAS y C. KELLY, European Convention on Human Rights Act: operation, impact and analysis, Thomson-Round Hall, Dublín, 2010.
  • F. DE LONDRAS, “Neither Herald nor Fanfare: The Limited Impact of the ECHR Act 2003 on Rights Infrastructure in Ireland”, en S. Egan, L. Thornton y J. Walsh (eds.), Ireland and the European Convention on Human Rights: 60 Years and Beyond, Bloomsbury, Dublín, 2014.
  • L. EARNER-BYRNE y D. URQUHART, The Irish Abortion Journey, 1920-2018, Palgrave, Cham, 2019.
  • G. ESCOBAR ROCA y R. GARCÍA MANRIQUE, Argumentación e investigación en derechos humanos, Tirant lo Blanch, Valencia, 2019.
  • D. FENNELLY, International Law in the Irish Legal System, Round Hall, Dublín, 2014.
  • S. FREDMAN, Human Rights Transformed: Positive Rights and Positive Duties, Oxford University Press, 2008.
  • T. HICKEY, “Popular Sovereignty in Irish Constitutional Law”, Dublin University Law Journal, nº 40 (2), 2017.
  • T. HICKEY, en “Judges as God’s philosophers? Re-thinking principle in constitutional adjudication”, en L. Cahillane, J. Gallen y T. Hickey (eds.), Judges, Politics and the Irish Constitution, Manchester University Press, 2017.
  • G. HOGAN, D. KENNY y R. WALSH, “An Anthology of Declarations of Unconstitutionality”, The Irish Jurist, nº 54, 2015.
  • G. HOGAN, “Constitutional interpretation”, en F. Litton (ed.), The Constitution of Ireland 1937-1987, Institute of Public Administration, Dublín, 1988.
  • G. HOGAN, “Directive Principles, Socio-Economic Rights and the Constitution”, The Irish Jurist, nº 36, 2002.
  • G. HOGAN, “The Constitution and the Convention: Happily Married or a Loveless Co-existence?”, en S. Egan, L. Thornton y J. Walsh (eds.), Ireland and the European Convention on Human Rights: 60 Years and Beyond, Bloomsbury, Dublín, 2014.
  • G. HOGAN, “Unenumerated Personal Rights: The Legacy of Ryan v. Attorney General”, en L. Cahillane y otros (eds.), Judges, Politics and the Irish Constitution, Manchester University Press, 2017,
  • G. HOGAN, “Unenumerated Personal Rights: Ryan’s Case Re-evaluated”, Irish Jurist, nº 25-27, 1990-1992.
  • G. W. HOGAN y otros, Kelly: The Irish Constitution, Bloomsbury, Dublín, 5ª ed., 2018.
  • G. W. HOGAN, “The Constitution, Property Rights and Proportionality”, The Irish Jurist, nº 32, 1997.
  • R. HUMPHREYS, “Interpreting Natural Rights”, Irish Jurist, nº 28-30, 1993-1995.
  • J. KAVANAGH, Constitutional Law in Ireland, Clarus Press, Dublín, 2018,
  • A. KENNEALLY y J. TULLY, The Irish Legal System, Clarus Press, Dublín, 2013.
  • R. MAC CORMAIC, The Supreme Court, Penguin Books, Dublín, 2017.
  • V. O’MAHONY, “The Right to Education and Constitutionally Appropriate Provision”, Dublin University Law Journal, nº 28, 2006.
  • J. C. MacNEILL, The Politics of Judicial Selection in Ireland, Four Courts Press, Dublín, 2016.
  • P. A. McDERMOTT, “The Separation of Powers and the Doctrine of Non-Justiciability”, The Irish Jurist, nº 35, 2000.
  • M. MILLAR, “Health care: consumer purchase or social right?”, en N. Collins y T. Cradden (eds.), Political issues in Ireland today, Manchester University Press, 3ª ed., 2004,
  • K. MÖLLER, The global model of constitutional rights, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2012.
  • D. G. MORGAN, “Judicial Activism – Too much of a Good Thing”, en T. Murphy y P. Twomey (eds.), Ireland’s Evolving Constitution 1937-97: Collected Essays, Hart, 1998,
  • S. MULLALLY “Substantive equality and positive duties in Ireland”, South African Journal on Human Rights, nº 23, 2007.
  • T. NÍ MHUIRTHILE, C. O’SULLIVAN y L. THORNTON, Fundamentals of the Irish Legal System, Thomson-Round Hall, Dublín, 2016.
  • M. O’FLAHERTY, “Irish Foreign Policy and Human Rights”, en S. EGAN, International Human Rights: Perspectives from Ireland, Bloomsbury, Dublín, 2015.
  • O. DOYLE, Constitutional Law: Text, Cases and Materials, Clarus Press, Dublín, 2008.
  • O. DOYLE y T. HICKEY, Constitutional Law: Text, Cases and Materials, Clarus Press, Dublín, 2019.
  • R. O’HANLON, “Natural Rights and the Irish Constitution”, Irish Law Times, nº 11, 1993.
  • K. O’HALLORAN, Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity and International Human Rights Law, Routledge, Abingdon, 2020.
  • M. L. PARIS, “The European Convention on Human Rights: Implementation Mechanisms and Compliance”, en S. Egan (ed.), International Human Rights: Perspectives from Ireland, Bloomsbury, Dublín, 2015,
  • T. PERNOT, “The Right to an Environment and its effects for climate change litigations in Ireland”, Trinity College Law Review, nº 22, 2019.
  • J. ROONEY, “International Human Rights as a Source of Unenumerated Rights: Lessons from the Natural Law”, 2019.
  • C. SMYTH, Social and Economic Rights in Ireland, Clarus Press, Dublín, 2017.
  • E. VÍRGALA FORURIA, La Constitución británica en el siglo XXI, Marcial Pons, Madrid, 2018,
  • VVAA, “Encuesta”, Teoría y Realidad Constitucional, nº 41, 2018.
  • G. WHYTE, Social inclusión and the legal system, IPA, Dublín, 2ª ed., 2015.
  • G. WHYTE en “The Role of the Supreme Court in Our Democracy: A Response to Mr Justice Hardiman”, Dublin University Law Journal, nº 28, 2006
Fuente de los datos: Dialnet